Showing posts with label alcohol. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alcohol. Show all posts

Thursday, 20 November 2008

Secret drinkers

Almost 2 in 5 people who drink above recommended limits of alcohol lie to doctors about their excesses according to a survey. 

According to a BBC source, in poll of 2000 people, men were more likely to downplay their drinking habits than women. 

Those who drank sensibly tended to be honest, where as 39% of those risking their health with drink, lied.

This doesn't surprise me. I remember a psychiatrist giving us medical students advice on questioning patient's drinking habits. 

He said you should always casually overestimate how much they drink, for example with, "how much do you drink a night? 40 beers?" 
The reply could be anything from shock, to an honest, "Oh no not that much, probably 30".

Tell tale signs
When I was 17 years old and thinking about applying for medical school, I had a work experience placement at a GP surgery. I saw a lady perhaps in her 60s, who was suffering from early signs of dementia. She was becoming forgetful and was unable to complete a test which involved filling in the numbers of a clock face. 

When the doctor asked about her alcohol intake, the patient said she enjoyed a couple of beers a night. The doctor was quick to assume that it was a great deal more than that. Her forgetfulness was likely to be a case of alcohol dementia.

It is not unusual for someone to feel ashamed about over drinking when it becomes a problem. It might often be the case that patients don't want to admit to themselves that they have a problem. Sometimes the units just creep up without the person even realising.

It is a shame because there is often help (such as alcoholics anonymous) out there, but by the time they've admitted their problem, their physical health has irreversibly deteriorated. 

It is always hoped social support will reach them before medical care is needed.

Saturday, 1 November 2008

Does Alcohol do Good to the Unborn Baby?

Yesterday it was said, that mothers who drink alcohol modestly during pregnancy are more likely to have better behaved children than those who do not drink at all. 

The study has followed confusion in the past month about whether or not it was safe during pregnancy to drink at all. The government does not recommend complete abstinence, where as the National Institute for Healthcare and Clinical Excellence (NICE) gives opposite advice.

The study at University College of London were looking to see if there was a link between light drinking during pregnancy and cognitive or behavioural problems in the children at the age of three.

Better Behaved
Not only did researchers find toddlers did not suffer cognitively and behaviourally, but also that a significant proportion of the toddlers of mothers who drank during pregnancy seemed to be doing better than those who abstained.

Boys were 40% less likely to have conduct problems and 30% less likely to be hyperactive. Girls were 30% less likely to have emotional and peer problems.

Therefore it is possible that advice not to abstain may be favourable. Light drinking however, means light ie. 1-2 units per week or per occasion. When mothers drank heavily during pregnancy their children were more likely to have problems than abstainers.

Whose Advice is Best?
There is always the risk of women drinking too much if told it is a good idea to drink alcohol during pregnancy, that could lead to more serious effects than abstaining. Pat ''O Brien, a consultant at UCL, said about the Department of Health's views to abstain from drinking that: "They took that stance because they felt that in population terms it was the best way of deterring women from drinking too much in pregnancy." 

Light drinking may advantage children cognitively but it may cause other health problems. Dr. Kelly who carried out the study said: "There is inconsistency in policy around this issue and studies such as this one are vital in light of the wider debate around drinking and pregnancy."